I won't rank them all, just call out some that particularly strike my fancy. That's not to say the ones I don't list here I dislike or anything, just I have more opinions about what seems cool then the stuff that's basically just “that sounds fine”.
Stuff I've been itching to try for a while: Mage: The Awakening, Blue Planet (for the setting), D&D 5e (for the rules), Rogue Trader.
Stuff that sounds intriguing: new Changeling, Hellfrost, Transhuman Space, Mage Sorceror's Crusade, Colonial Gothic
Stuff we've played that I'm always happy to play more of: Trystell Reborn, Shadows over Sol
Cool! So by now most people have responded, and there is a good general overview of people's interests.
Let's see if we can come to some sort of consensus around a specific game.
So, am I wrong in that Torchbearer seems like “Roguelike: The Tabletop RPG”?
Either way, everyone seems somewhere between vaguely interested to very interested to not offended by and it's new and interesting?
Mage: the Awakening and Torchbearer do seem to be the frontrunner options and I'd be happy to do either.